Notizie
-
13
giugno
2024
June 26th exam postponed - Spostamento esami del 26 giugno 2024
Due to unforeseen commitments, the exam scheduled for June 26, 2024, has been moved to the following day, June 27, 2024, at 9:00 AM. I apologize for the inconvenience.
A causa di impegni imprevisti sopravvenuti, l'esame del 26 giugno 2024 è spostato al giorno seguente, 27 giugno 2024, alle ore 9:00. Mi scuso per il disagio.
-
24
aprile
2024
FINAL EXAM (2nd part): materials
Below, I am publishing the detailed program for the final exam (second part of the course for Fundamental Rights - 9 CFU enrollees and comprehensive exam for students enrolled in the 6 CFU exam).
Topics References
Constitutional Courts and Constitutional Adjudication
A. Stone Sweet, Constitutional Courts, in The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law, edited by Michel Rosenfeld and András Sajó
(a copy of the book is available in the University library)
The Italian Constitutional Court and Constitutional Adjudication
Effects of the ICC decisions
(ICC, No. 10/2015)
Chapter 9 of Textbook
Fundamental rights: concepts and classifications
S. Gardbaum, The structure and the scope of constitutional rights, in The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law, edited by Michel Rosenfeld and András Sajó
(a copy of the book is available in the University library)
Chapter 10 of the textbook
Interaction between Constitutional Law and International Law
A. Cassese, 12. The Implementation of International Rules within National Systems, in A. Cassese, International Law, 2nd Edition (OUP 2005)
(a copy of the book is available in the University library)
Supranational systems of protection of fundamental rights: the ECHR and the CFREU
W.A. Schabas, Adoption of the Convention, in The European Convention on Human Rights. A Commentary, edited by W.A. Schabas
(a copy of the book is available in the University library)
Proportionality & Balancing rights
B. Schlink, Proportionality (I), in M. Rosenfeld and A. Sajó (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law (OUP 2012)
(a copy of the book is available in the University library)
The Italian Constitution in the European legal area
- European Journey of the ICC
- Counter-limits doctrine
- The ECHR in the Italian legal systemChapter 2 of the textbook
Multilevel Protection of fundamental rights under the CFREU and the ECHR
- ICC Nos. 348-349/2007
- Preliminary reference
- Dual Preliminarity (ICC No. 269/2017)Life imprisonment
- ECtHR, Viola v Italy (2), App. No. 77633/16 - Italian Constitutional Court, judgment No.
253/2019
- G. Minervini, Viola v Italy: A First Step towards the End of Life Imprisonment in Italy, 2020, in Italian Yearbook of International Law
Right to liberty
- ECtHR, 15 March 2012, Austin and others v the United Kingdom, App. Nos. 39692/09, 40713/09, 41008/09
- ECtHR, 23 February 2017, De Tommaso, App. 43395/09- L. Graham, Liberty and its exceptions, in International and Comparative Law Quarterly, vol. 72, April 2023 pp. 277–308
End-of-life decisions (Cappato case)
- Italian Constitutional Court, No. 242/2019,
Cappato
- F. Turoldo, Aiding and Abetting Suicide. The Current Debate in Italy, in Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 2021, pp. 123–135 (M)
Same sex marriages and gay family life
- Italian Constitutional Court No. 138/2010
- ECtHR, 21 July 2015, Oliari and others v Italy, App. Nos. 18766/11 and 36030/11
- S. Ragone, V. Volpe, An Emerging Right to a “Gay” Family Life? The Case Oliari v. Italy in a Comparative Perspective, in German Law Journal, Vol. 17, Issue 3 , 01 June 2016, pp. 451 – 485 (M)
Principle of laicité
- ECtHR (Second Section), 3 November 2009, Lautsi v Italy, App. 30814/06
- ECtHR (Grand Chamber), 18 March 2011, Lautsi v Italy, App. 30814/06- L. Zucca, Lautsi: A Commentary on a decision by the ECtHR Grand Chamber, in International Journal of Constitutional Law, 2013, pp. 218-229
-
15
aprile
2024
Seminar: Hate Crimes and Denialism - April 16, 2024
Corso di Laurea in International, European and Comparative Legal Studies (IECoLS) - Fundamental Rights - A.Y. 2023-2024
__________________________________________
Hate crimes and denialism: where freedom of expression meets criminal law
Dott.ssa Laura D'AMICO
Università di Messina
Introduce
Dott. Giacomo MENEGUS
MARTEDÌ 16 APRILE 2024
14.00-16.00 | Aula 2
Dipartimento di Giurisprudenza
-
29
marzo
2024
Mid-term written test results - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS 23-24
Student
Grade
112639
23
115174
19
111910
30
114370 (or 114310?)
20
114101
24
S.M. (no registration number)
24
113836
30 cum laude
112852
30 cum laude
111835
29
114051
18
113801
18
112934
30
112851
29
114109
25
114236
20
112209
30 cum laude
113505
26
112482
30 cum laude
112640
25
-
28
febbraio
2024
SECOND PART OF THE COURSE - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS 23-24
Dear students,
I am pleased to inform you that the second part of the course, which corresponds to the Constitutional Law exam worth 6 CFU, will start on Wednesday, March 6, 2024. I will publish the detailed syllabus of the second part of the course later this week.
-
28
febbraio
2024
MID-TERM WRITTEN TEST - FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS 23-24
Dear students,
As mentioned during the last lecture, I would like to inform you that the mid-term written test on the first part of the course will take place on Tuesday, March 19, 2024, at 2:00 PM in Classroom 2 (floor -3). The test will last for one hour and will consist of 5 open-ended questions. I kindly ask you to be punctual at 2:00 PM. I will provide the answer sheets. Thank you.
-
15
novembre
2023
EXAMS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS DEC 2023 – JAN 2024
The exams of Fundamental Rights of December 2023 and January 2024 will be supervised by Prof. Chiara Bergonzini, since Prof. Menegus is going to be abroad for a research stay.
To sign up for the exams in December 2023/January 2024, it is necessary to select the exam dates of Prof. Bergonzini instead of those of Prof. Menegus.
-
15
novembre
2023
APPELLI DICEMEBRE 2023/GENNAIO 2024 DIRITTO COSTITUZIONALE
DIRITTO COSTITUZIONALE (L-14)
Gli appelli di Diritto costituzionale per l’a.a. 2022/2023 saranno svolti dal Dott. Menegus fino a febbraio 2024.
Gli appelli di dicembre 2023 e gennaio 2024 saranno tuttavia presieduti dalla Prof.ssa Chiara Bergonzini, in quanto il Dott. Menegus sarà all’estero per un soggiorno di ricerca.
I compiti saranno comunque predisposti e corretti dal Dott. Menegus.
Per iscriversi all’esame negli appelli di dicembre 2023 e gennaio 2024 è necessario selezionare gli appelli della Prof.ssa Bergonzini (che sarà formalmente Presidente della Commissione d’esame).
-
23
gennaio
2023
ONLY for students of Constitutional law - A.Y. 2021-2022
Until the end of the current session of exams (March 2023), students attending the course Constitutional Law in Academic Year 2021-2022 with Prof. A. Cossiri may take the examination with the previous year's program (see here).
For enquiries contact: giacomo.menegus@unimc.it
-
23
gennaio
2023
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – 6 CFU
For students who have to take the Constitutional Law – 6 CFU exam, the program is the following and corresponds to the second part of the course of Fundamental Rights – 9 CFU.Nonetheless, participation in the first part of the late is strongly recommended as a helpful opportunity to refresh knowledge of Diritto costituzionale 1.
Obiettivi formativi
In the second part of the course (6 CFU), particular attention will be paid to the Italian Constitutional Court’s role and the degree of protection granted to fundamental rights by courts at different levels (multilevel protection of fundamental rights). The use of court cases in the lectures will make students deal with first-hand materials, facilitating them to acquire familiarity with vocabulary and valuable practice for their academic and professional careers.
Prerequisiti
Basic knowledge of Italian constitutional law is necessary, as acquired in Diritto costituzionale 1.
Contenuti
The second part of the course (6 CFU) aims to set the Italian constitutional system in the European legal area. A list of crucial court cases from the Italian Constitutional Court, the European Court of Human Rights, and the Court of Justice of the European Union is analysed to reconstruct the system of fundamental rights protection in the European context. Most of this second part of the course will be focused on cases and precedents to stimulate discussion during the classes.
The main topics are the following:
- The Italian Constitution in the European Legal Area
- Italian Constitutional Court and Constitutional Adjudication
- Multilevel Protection of Fundamental Rights
- Selected case-law
Metodi didattici
Except for the introduction to constitutional adjudication and the theory of fundamental rights, the second part of the course (6 CFU) has a solid practical approach. Students will be involved actively in class discussions of the cases: small groups of discussion leaders will be selected for each class to present specific cases to their colleagues under the supervision of the Professor.
Renowned scholars may be invited as guest speakers.
Modalità di valutazione
Oral examination. The student will be required to show their knowledge of constitutional law and the ability to apply it to practical cases. The student is expected to analyse sources and theories independently and use the appropriate legal vocabulary, thus proving that they have acquired the study method.
The evaluation criteria are the following:
- knowledge and understanding of constitutional law/fundamental rights law and ability to apply them to concrete cases (65%);
- appropriate use of legal vocabulary, ability to analyse and evaluate sources, and acquisition of the study method (35%).
Testi
(A) Cartabia, Lupo, The Constitution of Italy. A Contextual Analysis, Bloomsbury, 2021 (Chapters 2, 8, 9, 10)
(C) Barsotti, Carrozza, Cartabia, Simoncini Italian Constitutional Justice in Global Context Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2016
Non-attending students’ program for 6 CFU consists of Chapters 2, 8, 9, 10 of the Handbook and the materials provided during the second part of the course (available both on Teams and on the course's webpage).
-
21
marzo
2022
Climate Change Litigation & Constitutional Law - materials
To the students of Constitutional Law (Prof. A. Cossiri): all the materials of the course are uploaded on Teams; see "Climate Change Litigation & Constitutional Law" folder.